TICI – TABLEAU 7 (1) – Difficultés et problèmes mentionnés dans les études examinées classés selon le cadre conceptuel proposé

enq: résultats d’enquêtes – pb: problèmes mentionnés dans des revues des écrits et dans des recherches

PROCESSUS DE RECHERCHE D’INFORMATION

– Aspects affectifs durant la recherche

pb: considerable insecurity and uncertainty when searchingKuhlthau, 1991 (secondaire)
pb: feelings of confusion and frustrationAkin, 1998 (cf. Tood, 2001)

– Analyser le besoin d’information

enq: realization of the time and steps needed to get good info on their topicDaniel, 1997 (secondaire-univresité)

– Formuler des questions – Explorer le domaine


Générer des questions/des termes de recherche
pb: 10th Gr. students lacked sufficient knowledge to generate search terms

Gordon, 2000 (cf. Gunn, 2002)
pb: half the students (11 and 12 year old) interviewed stated they had difficulty developing these research-guiding questions and they had difficulty changing the wording of the questions they developedMoore, 1996 (cf. Gunn, 2002) (primaire)
pb: difficulté à choisir un terme de recherche pertinentOliver et Perzylo, 1994 (cf. Brodeur, 1996)
pb: the most significant problems their students encountered in database searching were « generating search terms » and « designing effective search strategies. »Neuman, 1995 (cf. Broch, 2000)
pb: des problèmes déclaratives qui semblent affecter la formulation des interrogations, certainement à cause des difficultés à correctement planifier (activer, sélectionner et organiser) les concepts liés à ces formulationsDinet, 1999

– Relever / classer les concepts

Générer des cartes de concepts
pb: those students who had been trained to be concept-mappers demonstrated more efficient and thourough searching behavior than non- concept-mappers.
Gordon, 2000 (cf. Gunn. 2002)
pb: persistence, motivation for task completion, the desire for accurary, the willingness to get the Internet’s organization, and the development of cognitive maps were characteristics that were repeated in many studies of high school and university students who use the Internet successfullyNahl, 1998 (cf. Gunn, 2002)
pb: The lack of schema creates difficulties when a child must modify his or her searchFidel et al., 1999 (secondairre); Nahl et Harada, 1996 (cf. Broch, 2000)

– Préciser la question – Le cas échéant, revoir la question


pb: high levels of information overload – inability to manage and reduce large volumes of information
Akin, 1998 et Watson, 1999 (cf. Todd, 2001)
pb: failure to retrieve documents based on aboutness
Bilal et Watson, 1998; McNicholas et Todd, 1996 (secondaire); Todd, 2000 (cf. Todd, 2001)

– Identifier les sources appropriées

pb: recognize and identify key electronic sources in their subject majorMaughan, 1994 – UC Berkeley

Site mis en ligne le 18 mai 2001. Tous droits réservés © 2001-2005. Paulette Bernhard. Dernière modification sur ce site: 16 février 2005.
Conception et réalisation: Paulette Bernhard, avec l’assistance de Zeïneb Gharbi
Veuillez envoyer vos commentaires et suggestions à: paulette.bernhard@umontreal.ca.